Check Price Now
Table of Contents
Questions such as What is forged steel? What is carbon steel? Is forged steel stronger than regular steel? are common when comparing forged steel vs. carbon steel. The choice matters, especially in India’s growing steel market, where demand from construction, infrastructure, automotive, railways, and renewable energy is rising.
With steel prices fluctuating and project requirements becoming more specialised, selecting the right grade helps avoid over-specification, failures, and additional expenses. This article explains the key properties, uses, and differences between forged steel and carbon steel to help you make informed procurement decisions.
What is forged steel?
Forged steel is an alloy of iron and carbon that is shaped through the forging process. In forging, steel is heated to a controlled temperature and then compressed under high pressure to achieve the required shape and dimensions. This process strengthens the metal and improves its overall performance.
Forging offers several key advantages:
- Refined microstructure with aligned grain flow, which increases strength and fatigue resistance.
- Higher ductility and tensile strength compared with many non-forged steels.
- Lower surface porosity and fewer defects such as shrinkage cavities or inclusions.
- Better toughness at extreme temperatures, making it suitable for harsh working environments.
Common Indian applications of forged steel include:
- Crankshafts, connecting rods, and axle parts in the automotive sector.
- Pressure vessels, flanges, and valves for oil, gas, and marine industries.
- Mining equipment, heavy-duty machinery, and high-load structural components.
Forged steel is chosen when reliability, durability, and impact resistance are critical.
Types of steel forging
| Forging type | Temperature range | Typical applications | Mechanical benefits | Common users (MSMEs vs. large plants) | Tolerances & accuracy |
| Cold forging | Up to 160°C | Fasteners, small automotive parts, hand tools. | Smooth surface finish, high dimensional accuracy, improved hardness. | Widely used by MSMEs due to lower energy costs. | Very tight tolerances possible; ideal for precision components. |
| Hot forging | 950°C–1300°C | Agricultural machinery parts, transmission components, flanges, shafts. | Excellent formability, strong grain flow, and high toughness. | Common across large forging plants and MSMEs. | Moderate tolerances; good for complex shapes requiring strength. |
| Hardened (heat-treated) forging | 750°C–950°C, followed by heat treatment | Defence components, railway parts, heavy-duty equipment. | High strength, improved wear resistance, reduced brittleness. | Mostly large plants with advanced heat-treatment facilities. | Used where enhanced durability and performance are required. |
What is carbon steel?
Carbon steel is an alloy of iron and carbon. Its performance depends on the amount of carbon present. As carbon content increases, the steel becomes harder and stronger, but less ductile and less weldable. Lower carbon levels improve formability and machining.
Carbon steel is widely used in India across construction, automotive, marine structures, power plants, fabrication, and general engineering. It remains popular because it is affordable, easy to source, and simple to work with, although it is more prone to corrosion than many alloy steels.
Carbon steel types based on carbon content include:
Low carbon or mild steel (up to 0.30%)
Used for:
- Pipes and tubes
- Wires
- CR and HR sheets and coils
- Structural fabrication
Medium carbon steel (0.30%–0.70%)
Used for:
- Railway axles
- Gears and shafts
- Automotive parts
High carbon steel (0.70%–2.5%)
Used for:
- Springs
- Cutting tools
- Blades and industrial tools
Carbon steel is chosen when buyers need strength, good machinability, and a cost advantage over forged or alloy steels.
Carbon steel types
| Type of carbon steel | Carbon content (%) | Relative hardness | Strength level | Machinability/weldability | Common Indian grades |
| Low carbon steel (mild steel) | Up to 0.30% | Low | Moderate | Excellent machinability and weldability. | IS 2062 (E250, E350), SAE 1008/1010. |
| Medium carbon steel | 0.30%–0.70% | Medium | High | Moderate machinability; reduced weldability. | C45, EN8, SAE 1040. |
| High carbon steel | 0.70%–2.50% | High | Very High | Low weldability; fair machinability with heat treatment. | EN9, SAE 1060. |
Forged steel vs. carbon steel: Key differences
As a steel buyer or user, it’s imperative that you understand what type of steel you require. The price of steel, its availability, properties, seller and multiple other factors must be considered before you buy steel for your business.
Here, let us look at the difference between forged steel vs. carbon steel, and understand which is the right choice for your project.
| Particulars | Forged steel | Carbon steel |
| Alloy type | Alloy of iron and carbon. | Alloy of steel with high concentrate of carbon (up to 2.5%). |
| Manufacturing process
(Also read: Steel manufacturing process) |
Produced using steel forging method that involves high temperature heating and application of pressure. | No special method of production – alloy made by adding high quantity carbon to steel. |
| Tensile strength | High tensile strength and fatigue resistance (suitable for high stress applications) and stronger than carbon steel | Low tensile strength and malleable (will be unable to sustain high stress). |
| Corrosion resistance
(Also read: Corrosion and Corten steel) |
High corrosion resistance. | Low corrosion resistance (needs to be coated or painted to prevent corrosion). |
| Longevity | More prone to wear and tear. | Less prone to damage. |
| Industry application | Construction and heavy machinery. | All engineering projects, tools, automotive components, construction. |
| Price of steel | Expensive compared to other steel types (due to the time-consuming and specialised forging technique of production and hence, availability). | Comparatively less expensive (does not require special production technique and is readily available). |
| Steel recyclability
(Also read: Steel recycling process and benefits) |
Complex, expensive and time consuming to recycle (has to be melted first). | Easy to recycle. |
What is drop forging steel?
Drop forging steel is produced by repeatedly striking a heated workpiece between dies, compressing and reshaping the metal. This process aligns the grain flow and increases density, giving forged steel higher strength, toughness, and fatigue resistance than ordinary carbon steel.
Drop-forged products include crankshafts, connecting rods, yokes, spanners, hooks, and engine parts, showing where forged steel adds value over carbon steel in strength-critical applications.
Why this matters for steel buyers
Understanding drop forging helps buyers match the right steel to the application. Components made by forging can handle higher loads, repeated impacts, and extreme conditions, justifying higher cost. Knowing the process also helps buyers assess quality, delivery timelines, and supplier capabilities, avoiding over-specification or failure in critical parts.
Types of forging and applications
Open-die forging: No closed cavity; ideal for large shafts, rings, and structural parts. Common in heavy engineering and railway sectors.
Closed-die forging: Metal flows into a shaped cavity; suitable for high-volume, repeatable production. Used in automotive, hand tools, and machinery.
Forged steel vs. carbon steel – How to decide?
Choosing between forged steel and carbon steel depends on performance needs, budget, lifecycle, and production requirements. Forged steel offers denser grain flow, higher toughness, and better fatigue resistance, while carbon steel is lower cost, easier to machine, and widely available. Selection should consider load type, impact, temperature, machining, and procurement factors such as MOQs, lead time, and regional availability.
Decision factors
Load, impact, and temperature: Forged steel excels under shock, vibration, cyclic, or high-stress loads. Carbon steel suits moderate, static, or ambient-temperature applications. High-temperature or dynamically loaded parts benefit from forged steel with aligned grain flow.
Machining, budget, and lifecycle: Carbon steel is faster to machine and more economical for high-volume fabrication. Forged steel costs more upfront but provides longer service life, fewer failures, and lower replacement costs.
Failure modes: Forged steel resists fatigue, cracking, and sudden impact failure, whereas carbon steel (especially non-heat-treated grades) is prone to early fatigue and brittle fracture under cyclic loads.
Scenario-based recommendations
Automotive OEMs: Use forged steel for crankshafts, connecting rods, steering knuckles, and shock-loaded components.
Structural frames & construction: Use carbon steel (IS 2062) for beams, braces, platforms, and general fabrication.
Hand tools & lifting hardware: Forged steel ensures toughness and safety.
General machinery: Carbon steel is sufficient for housings, plates, and non-load-critical parts.
Quality inspection checklist
Ensure procurement teams check:
Ultrasonic Testing (UT): Detects internal defects.
Hardness testing: Confirms mechanical strength and uniformity.
Dimensional inspection: Ensures parts meet design tolerances.
Mill Test Certificates (MTC): Verifies chemical composition and grade.
Heat treatment verification: Confirms proper tempering and strength.
Supply chain & procurement insights (India)
Lead times: Forging shops usually have longer production schedules than mills.
Regional clusters: Major hubs include Pune, Rajkot, Ludhiana, and Jamshedpur.
Supplier specialisation: Some focus exclusively on carbon-steel forgings due to equipment or expertise.
Sourcing options: Stockyards offer quick delivery, mills provide bulk consistency, forging shops deliver customised high-strength parts.
Pricing & MOQ: Forged steel often has higher MOQs and fluctuating prices due to die and energy costs. Carbon steel is more stable and widely available.
Regional availability: North India (Punjab, Haryana) has dense forging clusters; West India (Maharashtra, Gujarat) supports fast carbon-steel supply; South India (Tamil Nadu, Karnataka) offers strong machining support.
Market trends in forged steel and carbon steel (2024–2025)
Growth in automotive and railways driving forged-steel demand
India’s forged-steel market is expanding as vehicle makers and rail OEMs increase orders for high-strength components such as crankshafts, axle parts and traction hardware. Industry estimates put the Indian forged-steel market in the multi-billion-dollar range with steady mid-single-digit to high-single-digit CAGR projections through the late 2020s.
Infrastructure push lifts carbon-steel consumption
Large government projects, roads (Bharatmala), urban and rail modernisation (including Vande Bharat train programmes), are fuelling demand for structural, plate and long products. This has supported a rise in finished steel consumption and higher mill activity in 2024–25.
Import/export considerations
India’s trade balance in steel swung through 2024–25: the country was a net importer in some months but returned to net-exporter status intermittently as global demand shifted. New external pressures, such as the EU carbon border rules, are prompting Indian mills to reconfigure export strategies and focus more on domestic demand. Expect volatility in trade flows and pricing into 2026.
Challenges MSMEs face in sourcing forged components
Most forging capacity is split between large plants and many small/medium units. MSMEs face constraints including access to finance, digital adoption gaps, energy and skill shortages, and longer lead times for specialised dies or heat-treatment services. These bottlenecks affect quality consistency and timely delivery for OEMs that rely on local forged suppliers.
Cost comparison: Forged steel vs. carbon steel in India
| Factor | Forged steel | Carbon steel |
| Why it costs more | Energy-intensive heating, skilled labour, die manufacturing, longer processing cycles. | Mass-produced in mills, automated rolling and finishing, lower labour intensity. |
| Typical cost difference | 20–60% higher than equivalent carbon steel parts, depending on complexity and forging type. | Baseline cost; varies by grade (low/medium/high carbon). |
| Cost reduction levers | Bulk orders, long-term supply contracts, shared die costs, and predictable annual volumes. | Bulk procurement, mill contracts, buyer consolidation, off-peak purchasing. |
| Pricing drivers in India | Forging shop energy costs, die/tooling charges, alloy additions, heat-treatment cycles. | Coking coal prices, iron ore availability, mill capacity utilisation, global scrap rates, import duties, logistics. |
Alternatives to forged and carbon steel
In some applications, alloy steels, stainless steels, or cast steel may outperform forged or carbon steel. Alloy steels offer enhanced strength, wear resistance, and fatigue performance, ideal for high-stress or high-temperature components. Stainless steel provides superior corrosion resistance, making it suitable for marine, chemical, and coastal environments. Cast steel is useful for complex shapes or large structural components where forging is impractical.
When to consider alternatives to forged steel
Forged steel may be unsuitable for very thin, intricate, or decorative components where machining or casting is easier and more cost-effective.
When to consider alternatives to carbon steel
Carbon steel is not recommended in high-corrosion environments (coastal zones, chemical plants) unless properly coated or galvanised, as it rusts faster than stainless or alloy steels.
Selecting the right material ensures cost efficiency, performance, and long-term durability for Indian buyers and OEMs.
Conclusion
Forged steel and carbon steel each serve distinct purposes in India’s growing steel market. Forged steel offers superior strength, toughness, and fatigue resistance for high-stress components. Carbon steel is cost-effective, widely available, and suitable for general fabrication and structural work. Choosing the right steel type depends on load, environment, lifecycle, and budget considerations. Understanding properties, applications, and supply-chain factors ensures smarter procurement and long-term project efficiency.
Looking to procure steel?
Tata nexarc helps manufacturers, builders and MSMEs source certified steel products, compare prices, and choose the right grade as per IS codes—with complete traceability and procurement confidence.
FAQs
Is forged steel better than cast steel?
What are the most common forged steel components used in India?
Which industries in India consume the most carbon steel?
Can forged steel be welded?
Which steel type offers better ROI in long-term applications?
What makes forged steel stronger than standard carbon steel?
Can carbon steel be heat-treated like forged steel?
Are forged steel components more expensive in India?
Which Indian regions specialise in forged steel supply?
How do I choose between forged and carbon steel for high-temperature applications?
Sohini is a seasoned content writer with 12 years’ experience in developing marketing and business content across multiple formats. At Tata nexarc, she leverages her skills in crafting curated content on the Indian MSME sector, steel procurement, and logistics. In her personal time, she enjoys reading fiction and being up-to-date on trends in digital marketing and the Indian business ecosystem.
