Differences between 3PL and 4 PL: Which is better for your business?

Table of Contents

Third-party logistics (3PL) and fourth-party logistics (4PL) may sound similar, but their roles in the supply chain differ in scope and responsibility. Let us explore their differences. 

Put simply, a 3PL provider focuses mainly on execution. It manages specific logistics functions such as warehousing, transportation, distribution, or order fulfillment. Businesses often outsource these activities for efficiency and to reduce costs. In a 3PL set up, the company retains overall control of its supply chain strategy, with the third party handling day-to-day operational tasks. 

A 4PL provider, on the other hand, takes on a more strategic role. Instead of just managing logistics activities, a 4PL integrates and oversees the entire supply chain on behalf of the business. This includes coordinating multiple 3PLs, technology systems, and resources, to optimise end-to-end supply chain solutions.  

Core differences between 3PL and 4PL 

Feature	3PL (Third-Party Logistics)	4PL (Fourth-Party Logistics)
Scope	Focuses on execution and operational tasks.	Focuses on strategic management and optimisation.
Role	Handles specific logistics functions such as warehousing, transportation, distribution, and order fulfillment.	Manages the entire supply chain process, including coordination of 3PLs and overseeing the entire logistics ecosystem.
Control	The company retains overall control of the supply chain, outsourcing specific functions.	The company hands over the management and strategy of the entire logistics chain to the 4PL provider.
Integration	Provides services in isolation, typically for one aspect of logistics.	Integrates and coordinates multiple logistics services, including 3PLs, technology systems, and resources.
Technology	May provide some technology solutions but generally focuses on logistics tasks.	Uses advanced technology platforms for end-to-end visibility, optimisation, and reporting.
Flexibility	Offers flexibility in specific functions, but the company maintains control over the logistics strategy.	Provides flexibility by offering end-to-end solutions and managing multiple service providers for optimal results.
Customer relationship	Typically interacts with the company’s operational team.	Works closely with senior management to design and optimise the supply chain strategy.
Example	A company outsourcing its warehousing or transportation needs.	A company outsourcing its entire supply chain management, including strategy, technology, and multiple logistics providers.

Is 3PL or 4PL more suitable for your business? 

MSMEs have varying logistics needs, and so, the choice between 3PL and 4PL services largely depends on the complexity and scale of your operations. Here’s a general overview of which logistics solution could be ideal for your business based on your industry. 

MSME Type	Best Fit for 3PL	Best Fit for 4PL
Manufacturers	When focusing on specific logistics functions such as warehousing or distribution.   If you need flexibility and control over your supply chain but want to outsource some operations.	If you require an integrated, optimised supply chain.     When dealing with multiple suppliers, distributors, 3PL providers, and need comprehensive management.
E-commerce Businesses	When you need cost-effective, efficient handling of packaging, shipping, and returns.   If you require support for last-mile delivery and regional fulfillment.	If you have a complex supply chain involving multiple partners and need strategic oversight across the entire logistics process.
Retailers (Brick-and-Mortar)	If you need dedicated logistics for inventory management, warehousing, or transportation.   For shorter-term, region-specific logistics solutions.	If you are expanding and need a long-term strategy for managing the entire retail supply chain, including multiple locations and vendors.
Import/Export Businesses	If you need support with customs clearance, transportation, and warehousing for specific markets.   When focusing on freight management, storage, and delivery.	If you need to manage a global supply chain with multiple logistics partners and require strategic coordination, customs compliance, and global distribution.
Food & Beverage	When in need of short-term logistics support for storage, transport, and delivery.   If you need to ensure timely delivery for perishable products.	If you need a comprehensive supply chain strategy to optimise sourcing, manufacturing, and distribution across various regions and partners.
Small-scale Distributors	When you need dedicated logistics support, such as transportation, warehousing, and stock management.   If you need to scale operations quickly without building infrastructure.	If you want an integrated, outsourced solution for managing inventory, distribution, and multiple service providers to ensure efficiency across the whole process.
Construction and Engineering	If you need help with materials delivery, storage, and transport, especially in different locations.     If your logistics requirements are project-based and need specific 3PL services.	If you need to manage logistics for large-scale projects across multiple regions, involving complex supply chains with multiple partners.

Key elements of 3PL and 4PL 

3PL logistics solutions 

• Transportation Management: Handling the movement of goods, including freight forwarding, shipping, and delivery. 

• Warehousing & Inventory Management: Storing goods and managing inventory levels, ensuring timely stock availability. 

• Order Fulfillment: Picking, packing, and shipping products to customers, often including returns management. 

• Customs & Compliance: Managing customs documentation and ensuring compliance with regulations for domestic and international shipments. 

4PL logistics solutions 

• Supply Chain Strategy & Optimisation: Designing and overseeing the entire logistics process, ensuring cost-effectiveness and efficiency across all stages. 

• Integration of Multiple 3PL Providers: Coordinating and managing multiple 3PLs, vendors, and partners to ensure smooth operations. 

• Technology & Data Management: Implementing and utilising advanced technology for real-time tracking, reporting, and analytics of the supply chain. 

• End-to-end Visibility: Providing comprehensive visibility across the entire supply chain, offering insights into performance, bottlenecks, and improvement opportunities. 

Top benefits of 3PL and 4PL logistics solutions for MSMEs 

 3PL 

• Cost Efficiency: Reduces operational costs by outsourcing logistics functions, eliminating the need for businesses to invest in warehousing, transportation, and staffing. 

• Scalability: Provides flexibility to scale logistics operations up or down based on demand, making it ideal for businesses with fluctuating needs. 

• Focus on Core Competencies: Allows businesses to focus on their core operations, such as manufacturing or sales, while leaving logistics tasks to experts. 

• Expertise & Industry Knowledge: Access to experienced logistics professionals who can streamline operations and ensure compliance with regulations. 

4PL 

• Comprehensive Supply Chain Management: Manages the entire supply chain, offering a holistic approach to improve efficiency and reduce costs across all stages of logistics. 

• Strategic Oversight & Optimisation: Provides a higher-level, strategic view of logistics, identifying opportunities for optimisation and long-term improvements. 

• End-to-End Visibility: Enables businesses to track the entire supply chain with real-time data, improving decision-making and operational transparency. 

• Technology Integration: Leverages advanced technologies to integrate various logistics functions, providing seamless communication and better coordination across all partners. 

Conclusion 

Essentially, 3PL is ideal for businesses seeking to outsource specific logistics functions while 4PL is suitable for MSMEs looking to optimise their entire logistics process. For businesses with complex supply chains or a need for long-term optimisation, 4PL is the way to go. 

FAQs

What is the main difference between 3PL and 4PL?

3PL focuses on executing specific logistics functions like transportation and warehousing, while 4PL manages the entire supply chain, overseeing multiple 3PLs and optimising logistics strategies. 

Can a business use both 3PL and 4PL services?

Yes. A business could use a 3PL logistics solution for specific functions like warehousing, while simultaneously using a 4PL solution to manage their supply chain. 

Which type of logistics provider is better for small businesses?

Small businesses typically benefit from 3PL services, as they are cost effective.  

How do 3PLs handle peak season logistics?

3PLs are experienced in managing peak season logistics by scaling up warehouse space, adding transportation resources, and streamlining fulfillment processes to handle increased demand efficiently. 

Can 4PL help in international logistics management?

Yes, 4PLs are well-suited for managing international logistics. They oversee global supply chains, handle customs compliance, and integrate multiple logistics providers to ensure smooth cross-border operations. 

What technology do 3PLs typically use?

3PLs typically use warehouse management systems (WMS), transportation management systems (TMS), and basic tracking software to streamline their logistics functions. 

Do 4PLs offer customised solutions for each business?

Yes, 4PLs offer tailored solutions based on the unique logistics needs of a business, to optimise efficiency. 

Are 3PL services suitable for businesses with international operations?

Yes. However, they typically focus on specific aspects like transportation, warehousing, and customs clearance, without managing the entire global supply chain. 

How do 3PLs ensure compliance with regulations?

3PLs stay updated on regulatory changes in various regions, managing compliance by ensuring proper documentation, timely filing, and adherence to local and international laws regarding shipping and storage. 

What kind of businesses should consider 4PL for their logistics needs?

Businesses with complex, multi-tier supply chains, large-scale operations, or international logistics needs should consider 4PL providers.